VILLER V35 BEWIJSMATRIX OBJECT HYPOTHESEN EN BRONKLASSEN 14-10-2026

{
  "project": "Familie Van den Berg(h) 3.0 — Viller Mühle",
  "round": "V35",
  "date": "2026-10-14",
  "mode": "ADD-ONLY",
  "new_independent_original_purchase_person_land_acts_first_read": 0,
  "newly_fetched_authentic_archival_images": 0,
  "no_originals_modified": true,
  "no_website_changes": true,
  "no_archive_contact_or_costs": true,
  "primary_sale_anchor": {
    "archive": "Landesarchiv Nordrhein-Westfalen AA 0633/3193",
    "scan": "0055",
    "post": 975,
    "date": "1806-08-05",
    "place": "Gennap",
    "name_ending": "-bergh",
    "name_beginning": "Vanbergh/Vonbergh ambiguous",
    "forename": "unresolved",
    "object": "deux moulins with grounds near Asperden formerly Neukloster/Graefenthal",
    "price_FRF": 10000,
    "total_settlement_FRF": 11006.07,
    "ledger_status": "Soldé",
    "legal_buyer": "NOG TE CONTROLEREN",
    "archival_image_already_saved_in_prior_rounds": true
  },
  "evidence": [
    {
      "id": "V35-01",
      "claim": "LVR 2019 explicitly describes two separate watermills at Viller circa 1600: grain and oil",
      "source": "https://www.kuladig.de/Objektansicht/KLD-294826",
      "source_class": "modern professional heritage research; not original circa-1600 inspection",
      "status": "BEWEZEN ALS GELEZEN SECUNDAIRE TEKST; oorsprong en juridische continuïteit NOG TE CONTROLEREN",
      "new_in_round": "precisely articulated distinction between two physical sites on Viller complex vs merely two functions; core LVR source already in older dossier"
    },
    {
      "id": "V35-02",
      "claim": "28 August 1600 water and mill inspection reportedly lists grain and oil mills at Viller",
      "source": "https://www.goch.de/bauen-wohnen/baudenkmaeler-goch/viller-muehle",
      "source_class": "official municipal historical summary; same wording reused on other websites",
      "status": "NOG TE CONTROLEREN op originele inspectieakte en signatuur"
    },
    {
      "id": "V35-03",
      "claim": "Tranchot/von Müffling 1803–1820 map excerpt shows old Niers-course and Viller mill location",
      "source": "https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:461_Tranchot_Viller_M%C3%BChle_Goch-Hommersum.jpg",
      "source_class": "reproduction of original historical map excerpt, low-resolution, modern red marker; map previously cited in project",
      "status": "BEWEZEN ALS CARTOGRAFISCHE AFBEELDING; NOT legal ownership, year 1806 unproven"
    },
    {
      "id": "V35-04",
      "claim": "Two mills in AA0633/3193 post975 were Viller grain and oil mills",
      "source": "AA0633/3193 existing original and LVR modern description",
      "source_class": "cross-source reconstruction",
      "status": "KANDIDAAT-OBJECTHYPOTHESE; NOG TE CONTROLEREN op 1806 adjudication/parcel identifications"
    },
    {
      "id": "V35-05",
      "claim": "Engelbert van de Loo acquired separate Aspermühle in 1805",
      "source": "https://www.kuladig.de/Objektansicht/KLD-298043",
      "source_class": "modern secondary heritage history",
      "status": "STERK-WAARSCHIJNLIJK secundair; original purchase act NOG TE CONTROLEREN"
    }
  ],
  "not_new_existing_sources": [
    "V30 LVR object discussion",
    "V31/32 existing sale volumes and register lacuna",
    "V33 comparable oil and watermill terminology from existing original",
    "V34 Engelbert genealogy",
    "13 Oct 2026 project original Tranchot map URL"
  ],
  "must_keep_separate": [
    "Viller grain watermill",
    "Viller oil watermill",
    "Aspermühle",
    "Hof zu Viller",
    "Oeffelt windmill",
    "Kessel windmill",
    "Vierlingsbeek–Maashees watermill"
  ],
  "next_priority": [
    "Original 1806 adjudication and parcel descriptions",
    "Original AA0633/3238 buyer balances",
    "Original AA0633/3112 cloister mill occupiers",
    "Original Engelbert Aspermühle 1805 sale",
    "Original inspection record dated 1600-08-28 and source archive identifier",
    "Gennep birth acts 1805 and 1806 original and Hommersum cadastral ownership"
  ],
  "citation_urls": [
    "https://www.kuladig.de/Objektansicht/KLD-294826",
    "https://www.goch.de/bauen-wohnen/baudenkmaeler-goch/viller-muehle",
    "https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:461_Tranchot_Viller_M%C3%BChle_Goch-Hommersum.jpg"
  ]
}