BEWIJSMATRIX HEPPENEERT BAPTISTA MATHIAS 1769 1775

{
  "project": "Familie Van den Berg 3.0",
  "date": "2026-11-02",
  "layer": "VDBH_HEPPENEERT_MAASEIK_1741_1769_1775_IDENTITEITSAUDIT_2026-11-02_ADD_ONLY",
  "checkpoint": "VBH-20261102-HEPPENEERT-1741-1769-1775-BAPTISTA-MATHIAS-BAGGEN-ANTI-MERGE",
  "protocol": "ADD_ONLY",
  "prior": "R336, latere 2-november themarondes incl Reynders_1725_1775, oudere R335/10okt, kandidaatwerk 26okt",
  "primary_1741": {
    "date": "1741-10-15",
    "couple": [
      "Joannes Baptista van Tongeren",
      "Elisabetha van de Bergh"
    ],
    "witnesses": [
      "Paulus van de Bergh",
      "Petrus van de Bergh",
      "Maria van de Bergh",
      "Harlindis van de Bergh"
    ],
    "evidence": "primary photo read in archived 10 October dossier, not freshly read this round"
  },
  "primary_1751": {
    "date": "1751-07-13",
    "couple": [
      "Josephus de Granade viduus",
      "Lindis van de Bergh"
    ],
    "witnesses": [
      "Joannes Mathias van Tongeren",
      "Mathias Postiens",
      "Maria van de Bergh",
      "Catharina van de Bergh"
    ],
    "evidence": "primary photo read in archived 10 October dossier; 5 May alternate wedding incorrect"
  },
  "indexes": [
    {
      "date": "1769-01-28",
      "notary": "PRINSSEN Joannes Ant.",
      "book": "III–286ab",
      "index_number": 121,
      "place": "Heppenaert",
      "names": [
        "Van de Bergh Lisbeth x Van Tingeren Jan Math.",
        "Van de Bergh Catharina",
        "Van de Bergh Harlindis wede Gernaedts Joseph",
        "Van de Bergh Jan + (Heppenaert)"
      ],
      "evidence": "modern surname index, not original notarial minute"
    },
    {
      "date": "1775-07-04",
      "notary": "van REIJ Joēs Wilhelmus",
      "book": "XIII–240bc",
      "index_number": 58,
      "place": "Bleumerstraat",
      "names": [
        "Van de Bergh Elisabeth zuster van Catharina",
        "Van de Bergh Catharina zuster van Elisabeth",
        "Van de Bergh Elisabeth x Van Tongelen Joēs B.",
        "Van de Bergh Nicolaes x Swiljens Maria Anna"
      ],
      "evidence": "modern surname index, not original notarial minute"
    }
  ],
  "name_models": [
    {
      "id": "A",
      "hypothesis": "same Baptist/Mathias or misread/inconsistent historic name",
      "status": "UNPROVEN"
    },
    {
      "id": "B",
      "hypothesis": "two distinct men and/or two distinct Elisabeths",
      "status": "UNPROVEN"
    },
    {
      "id": "C",
      "hypothesis": "notary lists historical or deceased husband and ownership context",
      "status": "UNPROVEN"
    }
  ],
  "candidate_parents": [
    {
      "id": "H",
      "parents": [
        "Joannes van den Bergh",
        "Sybilla Mevissen"
      ],
      "place": "Heppeneert",
      "status": "STRONG_CANDIDATE_FOR_1741_BRIDE_BASED_ON_WITNESSES_NOT_PROVEN"
    },
    {
      "id": "B",
      "parents": [
        "Gerardus van den Bergh",
        "Joanna Baggen"
      ],
      "place": "Maaseik",
      "status": "ALTERNATE_CANDIDATE_FOR_1775_SISTERS_AND_NICOLAES_UNPROVEN"
    }
  ],
  "source_csv": {
    "AL": "Notaris_aktes_AL_download_07-10-2026.csv",
    "MZ": "Notaris_aktes_MZ_download_07-10-2026.csv",
    "sha256": {
      "AL": "e5e56113bdc54544778cb890668f37faa412eabd786518a700d9ea2e5e0ac709",
      "MZ": "84e5b70567d047ce17581927b0c0d312b55cc6689573d436a6b9807f6fc5ed25"
    },
    "selected_index_rows": 22,
    "selected_notarial_acts": 2
  },
  "evidence_counts": {
    "new_primary_person_acts_read": 0,
    "new_original_scans_saved": 0,
    "new_direct_peter_ancestors_proven": 0,
    "new_independent_person_matches": 0,
    "indexed_name_rows_reproduced": 22,
    "website_changed": false
  },
  "non_merge_rules": [
    "Heppeneert vs Maaseik sibling groups separate",
    "Joannes Mathias vs Joannes Baptista not silently merged",
    "1769 Lisbeth vs 1775 Elisabeth unproven identical",
    "Nicolaes 1775 not labelled brother",
    "Maaseik Peter junior 1693 not proven Kessel 1722",
    "Kessel (D) ≠ Kessel (L)"
  ],
  "archive_inquiries_sent": false
}